SMUGDESK vs. X Rocker Surge 5172601: Which Gaming Chair is Better?

Between the SMUGDESK & X Rocker Surge 5172601; which gaming chair is the best?

Here it is ladies and gentlemen. Two highly popular gaming chairs side-by-side facing off. While each chair has its standard ups and downs, they also have their own unique benefits. Depending on what you’re looking for in a gaming chair will determine which of these might be the best choice for you. After extensive research, personal experience, and reviews; We formulated an in-depth comparison between each one. May the battle commence!  

But first…

What To Look For When Getting A Gaming Chair?

  1. Type of Chair: Does it have wheels, is it a rocker, or is it a stationary chair with a recline
  2. Comfort: The ability to remain comfortable for extended periods of time without fatigue
  3. Build Quality: The overall durability and longevity of the chair or the incorporated electronics (If it has any). This also includes the size and weight capacity
  4. Built-in Speakers: Many gaming chairs don’t provide built-in speakers, but the ones that do have an upper hand. Also, how good are the integrated speakers? 
  5. Massage Capabilities: Some chair’s provide massage capabilities, others don’t. 
  6. Appearance: Let’s face it, when you’re sitting down going into a gaming battle, you need your gaming chair to look cool and enhance the vibe of your room. 

We compared and contrasted each of these factors for the SMUGDESK & X Rocker Surge 5172601

SMUGDESK

X Rocker Surge

Type of Chair

There are a few types of gaming chairs. There are rocker chairs that typically sit closer to the ground and pleasantly rock back and forth. Then there are stationary chairs that might or might not provide a few levels of incline. And finally, there are gaming chairs with wheels with many similarities to a standard office chair. Each of the three has its own benefits. There isn’t necessarily a better or worse style as it comes down to your personal preference.

SMUGDESK
This chair provides a rocking mode or a tightened stationary position with the lever. However, it doesn’t recline backward too far. It is a PC gaming chair customized for playing video games on a computer. These chairs resemble a standard office chair. However, this chair is very versatile since it provides flip-up arms for arm freedom. So aside from computer game usage, the flip-up arms make it easy to play games with a controller such as PS4, Xbox, etc. Along with that, it also offers a 360-degree swivel and wheels for easy mobility.

X Rocker Surge 5172601
This is a rocker chair where you’re sitting close to the ground. we primarily recommend it for console gaming if you want to look slightly upwards at the TV. But for obvious reasons, we certainly don’t recommend it for PC gaming since you won’t even be able to reach your computer desk. Another beneficial factor worth mentioning is its foldability for effortless portability.  

Overall, the X Rocker Surge is a rocking chair that sits close to the ground optimized for console gaming. However, the SMUGDESK is a better option for PC gaming. 

Comfort

The ability to remain comfortable in your gaming chair for extended periods of time only makes your gaming or movie experience that much more enjoyable. If the chair possesses different recline levels or tilt, it’s also important to note which of the levels are comfy and which aren’t. 

SMUGDESK
This is one of the most comfortable PC gaming chairs on the market. Along with the ergonomic shape with the natural curve of your spine, both the bonded leather and high-density foam cushion help enhance the overall comfortability of this chair. Even for larger people, it remains comfy for extended periods without fatigue. Out of 10, we give it a 9.4 for comfort. It would get an even higher score if the center back padding wasn’t as thin as it was. 

X Rocker Surge 5172601
This chair possesses incredibly comfortable bonded leather material. Some people prefer lumbar support, others don’t. If you’re the type who doesn’t like lower back support, you’ll enjoy this chair’s comfort. However, we don’t recommend it for larger adults since you’re basically sitting on the floor. For medium-sized to smaller people, comfort is a solid 9.2 out of 10. 

Overall, the SMUGDESK is more comfortable. 

Build Quality

What good is your comfortable gaming chair with various features if it breaks sooner than you’d expected? The overall durability and longevity are crucial for any investment you make. Also, if the chair has any built-in electronics or speakers, it’s important they last long, as well. Another noteworthy attribute is the chair’s weight capacity and size. Some chairs might be a better fit for larger people, other chairs are better for medium to smaller people. 

SMUGDESK
With an impressive 300-pound weight capacity, this chair is remarkably tough. Out of 10, we give the overall build quality a 9. 

X Rocker Surge 5172601
The overall build quality is very sturdy. The overwhelming majority of people don’t have any issues with the inner electronics or longevity of the chair. Coming without wheels, this is a rocking chair. Therefore, if you prefer rocking back and forth while gaming or watching movies, you’ll be very happy with it. Another thing to keep in mind is its relatively compact size of 36.81 x 32.28 x 20.89. However, it’s remarkably able to hold up to 275 pounds. We give the overall construction a 9.5 out of 10.

Overall, the X Rocker Surge has a better build quality. 

Built-in Speakers

Some gaming chairs provide built-in speakers and others don’t. However, many people believe that gaming chairs with incorporated speakers are more valuable for gaming since it enhances a surround sound effect. But there are a few critical questions to keep in mind for chairs with built-in speakers. Are they wireless, or do you have to plug the chair in via cord? How good is the sound quality? And my personal favorite, does the chair have an integrated subwoofer that vibrates the chair according to the game? 

SMUGDESK
Doesn’t provide built-in speakers.

X Rocker Surge 5172601
With dual wireless Bluetooth speakers and an integrated subwoofer for enhanced bass, this chair produces great sound quality. Even though most TVs produce louder and a more clear sound than basically every gaming chair, this chair along with the TV enhances the surround sound effect. Both of the speakers are located at the top near your head while the volume control is on the bottom side. 

Overall, the X Rocker Surge is the only one of the two with incorporated speakers. 

Massage Capabilities

Some gaming chairs offer massage capabilities. While most don’t have this feature, it’s certainly a splendid option to have. Some people must have a massage chair, others don’t.

SMUGDESK
Although it’s not mentioned by the manufacturer, on the back of the chair is a pocket with a USB plug. You can plug it in for a decent vibration massage. 

X Rocker Surge 5172601
This chair doesn’t provide a massage feature. 

Overall, neither provide an integrated massage feature. 

Appearance

Gaming chairs can either dramatically enhance the overall vibe of your room, or not. Many gamers don’t care too much about how their chair looks. But if you’re like me and prefer a cool chair to sit down and battle aliens on your game, then the appearance is quite essential. 

SMUGDESK
You can get this chair in one of five color patterns. What we love most are the two holes on each top side and the stylish center. Compared to other gaming chairs, we consider the visual appearance smack dab average. Not bad at all, but nothing that’ll impress your friends. 

X Rocker Surge 5172601
With a compact but contemporary style, this chair offers a nice design. It won’t necessarily boost the overall aesthetic of your gaming set up, but it surely won’t hurt it, either. 

Overall, the X Rocker Surge 5172601 has a better visual appeal. 

Our Winner

Between The SMUGDESK & X Rocker Surge 5172601 Gaming Chairs 

Keep in mind that our opinion is not the end all be all. Like mentioned earlier, everyone has different needs, requirements, and budgets for their gaming chairs. However, our winner is the X Rocker Surge due to its enhanced build quality, rocking capabilities, and integrated speakers. However, if you’re primarily gaming on your computer, the SMUGDESK is a better option. 

If you’re interested in a 4K laser projector, see our top choices here